As the Susan G. Komen for the Cure foundation faces accusations that it split with Planned Parenthood
over political pressure, at least a couple pro-life groups are claiming
the organization may have acted out of concern over an alleged link
between abortion and breast cancer.
The theory that induced abortion increases
the risk of breast cancer has been studied for decades and is a
controversial one -- and one that is contested by major medical
organizations.
Komen for the Cure's website states that
despite debate over the subject, "research clearly shows no link between
the two." Komen asserted that position as recently as October 2011 in a
brief document on the debate.
As pro-choice organizations claim political
pressure led to the decision to cut ties, Komen also claims it was
merely following a new policy on grant recipients that is not unique to
Planned Parenthood.
But considering Komen for the Cure's
dedication to fighting breast cancer and raising breast cancer
awareness, the under-the-radar theory on an abortion-cancer link was
swiftly cited by some anti-abortion groups to explain why the
organization may have cut ties to the nation's largest abortion
provider.
American Right to Life blasted out a
statement Wednesday speculating that the purported link is the "real
reason" Komen split with Planned Parenthood.
"The pro-life pressure on Planned Parenthood
and Susan G. Komen is increasing," Lolita Hanks, president of American
Right to Life, said in a statement.
Karen Malec, president of the Coalition on
Abortion/Breast Cancer, said she suspects the link -- as well as the
prospect of donations drying up -- played a role in the decision.
"We know that Komen is working against their
mission by not telling women the truth about the abortion-breast cancer
link ... and by having this relationship with Planned Parenthood," she
told FoxNews.com.
Other theories abound. Several reports have
suggested that Komen's vice president, former Georgia Secretary of State
Karen Handel who was once endorsed by Sarah Palin, could be behind the
move.
Komen for the Cure did not respond to a
request for comment but organization founder Nancy Brinker released a
video Wednesday evening in which she stood by the Planned Parenthood
decision. The reason the group has given is that newly adopted rules
prevented Komen grants to groups under investigation by law enforcement.
Planned Parenthood is being investigated by Republican Florida Rep.
Cliff Stearns in Congress.
Brinker said the new policies will affect
"any number of long-standing partners," and claimed those policies have
been "mischaracterized."
"We will never bow to political pressure. We
will always stand firm in our goal to end breast cancer forever. We
will never turn our backs on the women who need us the most," she said
in the video. "The scurrilous accusations being hurled at this
organization are profoundly hurtful to so many of us who have put our
heart and soul and lives into this organization."
Brinker also said on a conference call
Thursday that funding decisions are not based on "emotions or politics."
With regard to Planned Parenthood, she said, "It was nothing they were
doing wrong" that led to Komen's decision.
The group was pilloried by pro-choice
supporters, including members of Congress, who described the move as a
partisan decision. Twenty-six senators wrote to Komen on Thursday urging
the organization to reconsider. New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg
announced he would match up to $250,000 in donations to offset the
funding cuts to Planned Parenthood.
Planned Parenthood, which also did not
return a request for comment from FoxNews.com, said in a statement it
was "alarmed and saddened" by the move, also charging that Komen
"succumbed to political pressure." One Komen affiliate in Connecticut
announced it would defy the national leadership and continue funding
Planned Parenthood. Another top Komen official reportedly has resigned
over the decision.
Neither Komen nor Planned Parenthood
mentioned anything about the alleged breast cancer-abortion link in
regard to the latest decision.
The theory is based on the idea that during
pregnancy, the surge in hormones in a woman's body ends up making the
breasts more susceptible to cancer as they increase in size. Completing a
pregnancy, though, allows what are known as "lobules" in the breast to
mature and become more cancer-resistant. According to the theory, having
an induced abortion before this stage cuts that process short.
According to the Breast Cancer Prevention
Institute, dozens of studies have shown an association between the
abortion and cancer. The group also cites statistics showing breast
cancer on the rise among women since 1970 -- suggesting the 1973
legalization of abortion may have played a role.
American Right to Life cited a 2009 study
that examined nearly 900 breast cancer cases and found induced abortion,
among other factors, was "associated with an increased risk for breast
cancer."
Cited by that study was another from 1994
that concluded the risk of breast cancer among women who had been
pregnant at least once was 50 percent higher for those who had induced
abortions.
The American Cancer Society,
though, declares that scientific research has not found a
"cause-and-effect relationship" between abortion and breast cancer. The
National Cancer Institute is on the same page.
As with many medical theories, what one study establishes, another refutes.
The American Cancer Society cited a major study out of Denmark
in the 1990s that it says found "no overall effect on the risk of
breast cancer." Similar results were found by Harvard researchers in
2007 and by researchers in California in 2008.
"The public is not well-served by false
alarms," the group says on its website. "At this time, the scientific
evidence does not support the notion that abortion of any kind raises
the risk of breast cancer or any other type of cancer."
The group also notes that some studies can
be skewed, because women with breast cancer may be more likely to report
their abortion history than healthy women.
But Malec said some of the studies cited by
ACS are flawed. And she claimed the concept behind the purported link
just makes sense.
"It turns on light bulbs in people's heads," she said.
No comments:
Post a Comment
You can comment here...